I wanted to add to/respond to some of the comments that caught my eye. I could totally relate to Fina's comment:Now my hair is in a protective style ~90% of the time and I feel slightly unsafe/guilty when I wear my hair out. Sometimes I too have felt almost bad when my hair is out and blowing around, just because I know it will cause more knots/split ends. I've learned to take it easier on myself and not get all stressed out over my hair. Sometimes it was like I forgot that I don't HAVE to have a length or growth goal just because everyone talks about it. And if I fall asleep one night without a freaking satin cap, my hair will still be ok...
And Jc makes a good point here: I understand what she is saying but I do think there are other protective styles that could make her feel cute. For example the classic two french braids. Perhaps a few cornrows in the front and free hair in the back tied into a bun. It is not all twists and box braids, there are alternatives.
Now here is another interesting comment from Deborah Estelle : But I like how some protective styles look like Roshini or even yours in your pictures but for some reason some women end up looking like the slavery era!
Sometimes when my hair was shorter especially, I remember feeling this way about twists. They just seemed so drawn up to my scalp. It did remind me of images I'd seen on tv of folks portraying slaves. It's nuts that those and big 70's afros are pretty much the only images I remember seeing as a kid of natural hair. Luckily that is changing but I totally know what she means.
And sometimes, like Moni said, it's all about practicality based on the environment in which you live: I wear protective styles all winter and wear my hair out most of the summer. Michigan winters are just too cold to leave my hair out.
These are for CocoEuro!
In the end, when it comes to protective styles, some of us like them, some don't. That's ok! It is nice to be able to choose how to wear your hair, whether it be relaxed or natural, kinky or straight, up or out. I guess I would only add that feeling guilty or bad about doing something to your hair is a waste of time and no fun! Hair should not dominate our lives or our self-esteem, although I know that can be easier said than done. Thanks to all who have shared so far and everyone else, feel free to chime in!
*******************************************************************
Taking a look around You Tube, I came across a video by SupremeDejhan entitled "I Don't Do Protective Styles..." I was intrigued because in the natural world protective styles are a mainstay, especially for those with length or health goals. I wear protective styles a lot nowadays that my hair has gotten longer. My hair tangles so easily and I get tons of tiny fairy knots if my hair is out for too long or gets blow around in the wind. Sometimes protective styles are less about my hair health and more for the sake of my mental health when I think about how un-fun it is to detangle a ratty mess!One thing she says in the video is that she does not want to sacrifice her cuteness for more length and that she is fine with the amount of hair she has. My mom even talks about how she does not like how her hair frames her face when it is in twists or other protective styles. She says that she needs "big" hair to frame her face in an attractive way.
My question to you all is, do you wear protective styles a lot? If so, it is for length retention, growth, health?
Do you feel attractive when your hair is in protective styles? If so, what are some of your favorites? If not, what else do you do to yourself (earrings, makeup, clothes, etc) to enhance your appearance?
In another clip of the video, she mentions not wanting to spend so much time with her hair in protective styles that she does not get to enjoy her hair. For some reason it made me think of my grandma's old house in the living room where all the "good" couches were covered in plastic! Like, we were saving them for when company came over but in the mean time we all had to look at that thick plastic. I know, random example, but it was the first thing that came to mind. Is it worth it to you to keep your mane twisted or otherwise "protected" if that means big hair is out for a while?
Please share your love (or love/hate or just hate!) relationship with protective styles! I would love to know what you think about this!



I try to wear in more protective styles but I usually don't like the results.It's hard for me to get it neat and not look dull. It's probably because I haven't honed my hairstyling skills and need to pratice more. I also seem to get more compliments when my hair is not in a protective style. I will keep trying to find a protective style that works for me. Health is more important than cuteness to me.
ReplyDeleteI haven't been doing protective styles because I am a sloppy braider/twister. My hair is super thick and to do small parts would take forever so I just do twist outs. I did get my hair blown out and professionally twisted almost 2 weeks ago. I'm dying to wash my hair but I paid so much money I want the style to last. It is weird having hair that points downward again.
ReplyDeletei dont wear protective styles that often and part of the reasons is because I don't like how braids or twists look on me. I just prefer to have wild big hair. So i understand what she means. Even When I do wear them its only for about a week. I get bored with them and I'm not creative when it comes to styling them in pretty updos.
ReplyDeleteI didn't get a chance to watch the video but I like the comparison you made between protective styles and your grandma's sofa. It's dead on.
ReplyDeleteThere are women out there that don't do any protective styling and still manage to retain length. I'm currently transitioning and I'm using a clip-on ponytail to try to switch things up but I'm really close to saying screw it and just enjoying my hair. I can honestly say I don't necessarily feel as pretty now as I did back when I did whatever I wanted with my hair. Buns, braids, twistouts, etc are becoming a huge bore!
Hi Leslie!
ReplyDeleteI wear my hair almost exclusively in protective styles. I keep my hair in double strand twists and I get TONS of compliments on my hair.
I don't do it for any of the three reasons that you suggested (length retention, growth, health). I do it because I'm a ridiculously busy college student and when I'm not doing school related work, I just don't have time to spend on my hair. I love waking up in the morning and not having to do anything more than pull my twist up in a high pony or if I have spare time (or I just want to look extra cute) I pin it up in a style.
I don't feel any less attractive when my hair is in twists than I do when my hair is loose.
At most I'll add earrings (usually hoops ... they're my fave type)a little mascara, some lip gloss and I'm good to go! :)
I don't do protective styles either. It's like if you're so scared to wear it down, what's the point in growing it out? You might as well cut it short. It kind of defeats the purpose of growing your hair out.
ReplyDeleteI can totally relate. I remember finding this video and feeling validated. Unfortunately, I'm at that in-between stage where my twists are too long to be short but not long enough to really style them. So I don't feel attractive in protective styles at all. But unlike SupremeDejhan, I DO want to grow my hair longer. So I'm working really hard to twist my hair once a week and wear it loose for 5-7 days while keeping it uber moisturized before rewashing/twisting/setting it for my next loose hair style.
ReplyDeleteI haven't watched the video yet but from your explanation of it I can really understand her pov and have even felt like that a time or two however in my experience I have been able to find flattering protective styles. I think twists are simply gorgeous and if they don't frame the face right I'd suggest a cute pinup style with the twists or perhaps even installing kinky twists or braids. I think the key is balance. It's not necessary to have protective styles on a permanent basis but perhaps half the time. I know styling the hair can take time but OMG i'd rather take that time and do my hair and have it last a week or so than having to stand in the shower or wherever I'm detangling my hair at for 30-45 minutes detangling because I let my do it's own thing for the sake of cuteness. Now don't get me wrong. I definitely do this at times but man it gets tiresome. Not to mention I'm sure I'm doing damage to the hair no matter how gentle I am when detangling. I think a healthy balance of both is a good thing in order to maintain health and look good. Just my opinion.
ReplyDeleteI never used to do protective styles because I found them boring and I'm really slow so they are time consuming.
ReplyDeleteHOWEVER, after observing the routines of those who have really long and healthy hair I came to the conclusion that protective styles are a necessity.
Now my hair is in a protective style ~90% of the time and I feel slightly unsafe/guilty when I wear my hair out. Its the same feeling I have when I sleep with nothing on my head. Perhaps its the dread of the monster detangling session yet to come...
I love my hair out. The only point when it is not out is when I am swimming. In fact if it wasn't for swimming, it would be out permanently all the time.
ReplyDeleteMy hair did grow when it was out, it just took a lot lot longer. I probably kept about 2 inches per year but much like the lady, once my hair got to about 10-12 inches I was pretty happy with it. Two years back when I swam all year round, I had amazing growth, seriously every 2 weeks when I took out the box braids I could see the difference. So yes protective styling does help the hair retain growth.
The fairy knots that you talked about were the reason I cut my hair back to its happy length (10-12 inches). I would get 3-4 knots per strand and would spend so much time hunting these things down.
I do think that sometimes the obsession with length leeds people to not enjoy their hair. I do think that even if protective styling is your mainstay, you can enjoy 1-2 days of free hair whenever you take out the style.
I think this lady is being honest to say that she doesn't feel cute (she clearly projects her lack of confidence which the kids she is teaching pick up on). I understand what she is saying but I do think there are other protective styles that could make her feel cute. For example the classic two french braids. Perhaps a few cornrows in the front and free hair in the back tied into a bun. It is not all twists and box braids, there are alternatives.
I don't like protective styles because I dont like how they frame my face. BUT keeping my hair in flat twists makes my life SO much easier since I dont have to worry about detangling/styling/etc. Irony--I think flat twist outs frame my face AND fit my style better than my wash and go @__@
ReplyDeleteInteresting! My hair isn't super long right now so I, too, don't like how my hair "looks" in protective styles. I am not a small woman and I feel more attractive with either really short hair or super big hair. The blessing is I'm prone to growth naturally so my hair grows no matter what! LOL! But I like how some protective styles look like Roshini or even yours in your pictures but for some reason some women end up looking like the slavery era! Not cute to me! But to each his/her own! Guess we need to be willing to take time and find the styles that work for us... The same way we did when we were relaxed!
ReplyDeleteI just started wearing my hair in protective styles!! and my hair loves me for it! It stays moisturized longer, it’s fuller, and shinier.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to be participating in a twist pin up challenge starting Monday for 6 weeks feel free join or stop by time-to-time...http://www.curlynikkiforums.com/general-f3/cn-pin-ups-t3355.htm#80096
Also, I love the pinup style at the top of this page...do you have more pics of it so that I can see the entire style?
About 99% of the time I am wearing my hair out. My wash n go's last about 3-5 days depending on A) the products I use to style initially and B) how/if I tie my hair up at night. As my hair gets longer I do experiment with different protective styles. My goal is to maintain the health of and grow my hair back to the length it was when I was relaxed, however I do want to enjoy my hair during the journey.
ReplyDeleteI watched a video by Kimmay on Youtube about protective styling where she said that she wears her hair out only a few times as a "treat." I think that's a good way to look at it.
ReplyDeleteProtective styling is PROTECTIVE and I don't see how that's a bad thing at all. It does take a little more creativity to make it look attractive on an adult woman at certain lengths. But it can and, I think, should be done.
I'm not only for protective styles of my hair but also head wraps and hats. The cute factor is all in how you present yourself.
I wear protective styles all winter and wear my hair out most of the summer. Michigan winters are just too cold to leave my hair out. I've found some quick, easy protective styles that I like (part hair in 4-8 sections, braid sections, bun ends), so I don't have a problem with it. I try to strike a good balance between out and protected.
ReplyDeleteI forgot to add that I do feel attractive with my protective styles, especially now that my hair is longer.
ReplyDeleteAhh interesting topic! I use to hate protective styles a few years back..It's taken me a while to really dig em but now I like rockin' my twists..I'll probably never do box braids because I've never liked them but twists are definitely good for busy schedules and that laziness that becomes us when we just ain't feelin' it :) I feel super cute when my hair is big though..I dunno what that is, maybe it's the attention or the free feeling I get. I gotta bring this up on my channel, I've always wondered if I was alone in my decision to be out more than tucked in when it comes to hair.
ReplyDeleteI would love to see a vid about this topic! Keep me posted!
ReplyDeleteWow this is the debate that I'm having with myself now. My hair just got to a length (ok, only like 4-5 inches) where my curly fros look fierce! I love them. I wear a hat everday at work (surgery) and I was still wearing curly fros! But this month I started wearing my hair in PS M-F like cornrows. My hair is way to short now and I am not a fan of the PS. I want to wear my fluffy hair out! But I make myself do it because I don't want to look up a year from now and my hair is like 3 inches longer! Plus, on Saturday when I wear it out I'm like "Oh fro, I missed you so much!" lolol
ReplyDeleteI'm just coming off of a year of protective styling, and my hair has suffered. On NC.com there is a thread about coarse hair and length retention. I'm fine haired, and my strands break pretty easily, especially with excess manipulation. So on the one hand I think certain protective styles can work for me, but not if done all the time. Buns and ponytails are fine if they are loose. Twists and braids are unfortunately for me, no-nos, unless it's a single braid or french braids (not cornrows or box braids). The occasional flat twist won't hurt, but on a regular basis they will break off my hair at the front and temples.
ReplyDeleteI'm one of those who feels super unattractive in protective styles. For me, it's because my hair is fairly short (6.5 to 7 inches) so twists -- my main protective style -- don't look nice when left down. But they are too short to put in nice updos unless I use a zillion bobby pins or make them really small which I am just too lazy to do. If I had your length Leslie, and could pin up my braids/twists/etc. into nice styles like the ones in your photos, I'd be ALL about the protective styling.
ReplyDeleteI love love love wearing my hair in twists. It's convenient, super cute (I wear them pinned up with some cascading in curls down the back of one side, kind of looks like a side pony) and it saves me so much time. I'll wear my hair out when I'm going out or on a date sometimes but on a regular basis, you'll find me in twists.
ReplyDeleteVery interesting. I have always been a fan of protective styling, even when I was relaxed, in that most summers and a few winters I'd keep my hair in extensions to give it a break. That's just how I grew up so it was normal to me.
ReplyDeleteHowever, now that I'm natural and trying to make an effort to protective style my own hair I must admit its been a little challenging. You have to put a little more effort into being creative about it because its easy for twists/braids/buns to end up looking a little "homely" on natural hair and bring out the more reserved side of us. I think the trick is to bring that same level of fierce confidence to your protected styles as many of us tend to exude with our fierce out styles.
IMHO, I think when you go the extra mile to make sure that your overall style looks as cute - pin up those twists, add the headband to the bun, super cute accessories - it tends to shine through regardless of how you've chosen to style.
So interesting to read this today. I twisted my hair this weekend out of frustration and managed to wear it for one business day before taking it down this evening. I felt it looked so awful, no length, no framing just bumpy and weird in the twist bun. Im now waiting for my fro to dry and will likely pull it back into a clip tomorrow. I think it varies for folks based on face, and hair length and texture. I look better with loose hair-I have wide jaw and need some framing to my face. I can get away with a braid/two but the twists/braids in abundance just look unattractive on me. Im now at a place where Im not willing to walk around all day feeling unattractive to "protect" my hair.
ReplyDeleteProtective styles would cause me more grief than benefit.
ReplyDelete1. My twists tend to unravel unless they're really large--too large for me to want to wear anywhere but to bed.
2. Any "pulled back" or "put away" style ages horribly. Minutes old cornrows look weeks old unless I straighten first.
3. My edges are really fine. To combat #2 cornrows, flat twists, etc would have to be very tight but they'd end up pulling my edges out.
I'm unwilling to deal with 1-3 because
4. I spent most of my life with my hair in a PS of some sort wishing to wear it out.
5. I feel more attractive with my hair out.
6. I enjoy handling my hair at night and in the morning.
7. I miss it when it's "away."
And most importantly
8. My hair seems to be doing just fine without protective styles. I retain length at a rate I'm happy with and don't have unbearable amounts of split ends or fairy knots.
The End :)
For me, the key to retaining length is not protective styles, it's low manipulation styles. As long as I don't have to comb my hair too often, it is fine. Even when I wear my hair out, it's okay because at night I just use my fingers to twist it up, then let it out in the morning.
ReplyDeleteHowever, some protective styles, such as twists, are not good for me because they knot up my hair so much that taking them down is more damaging than if I had left my hair alone.
I feel attractive no matter what my hair looks like. I feel strong being a natural. More than anything, I feel gross if I do not have on nice earrings or decided not to wear make up when in fact it would have been a better idea to have done so :)
ReplyDeleteI do a lot of protective styles at work - I would say 70% of the time. ALWAYS in the winter.
I was a big wash and go girl,(for 3 years) then after reading your blog and tutorials, I noticed a lot of growth once I started DCing and wearing more protective styles.
I would say I wear PS Mon - Thursday and the weekends (including Friday) are my fun hair days.
Keeps people guessing (including myself)which I find fun
I'm actually not sure. I just cut my hair in December and since then my 'safe' hairstyle *read style I think looks the best* is a coil out. I usually do it every four weeks so I think it makes it a protective style but I don't do it for protection. I just think it looks the best this way given that I don't have a lot of length.
ReplyDeleteI believe protective styles have helped my hair's length this past year. I was struggling with this issue, this week because after my ACV rinse I air dried and felt hella cute in my curls. But then I had to detangle and that was insane and I felt guilty because I know some damage was done.
ReplyDeleteEither way it is best to alternate and not be so strict with one self when it comes to hair care.